Involuntary disappearances have been a common feature of human rights abuses in the Punjab, India. The United Nations Working Group on Involuntary Disappearances is investigating more than 200 cases of disappearances in the Punjab. Human rights activists have long maintained that the real incidence runs into thousands but fear of recriminations by the police has prevented people reporting to the right authorities. In view of this, a two member committee of the Human Rights• Wing of the Akali Dal decided to investigate the matter from official sources. The findings are staggering. A preliminary count has shown that over 25,000 unidentified bodies have been registered in various municipal cremation grounds! These are people who ‘disappeared’ in the Punjab and their relatives still await news of their whereabouts.

The investigating team consists of Mr Jaspal Singh Dhillon and Mr Jaswant Singh Khalra. It started its work in August 1994. The records checked were;

Police records where available at the courts.
Municipal files on stock register where cremation records are held. Government oflndia, Birth and Death register.

Although threats were made by the police, the investigation was made public from the outset to prevent any recrimination. The statistical findings completed on two areas are as follows:

Patti Cremation grounds. Records from 1986 to 1994. show 1135 unidentified bodies.
Taran Taran; 1915.
Amritsar city; 2967.
Amritsar district total ; 6017.

This is just one district. There are 13 districts in Punjab.

Some of the specific cases are;
Bagel Singh alias Gurdarshan Singh of village Deriwal was abducted by the Pmtjab police from another province, Bihar. The news of his arrest was widely reported in the Punjab press. Various human rights organisations expressed concern for his safety fearing death by a faked encounter. On 19.1.92, the police, while fully aware of his identity, brought him to Durgiana mandir cremation grounds as unidentified and unclaimed body.
Mr Piara Singh s/o Shingara Singh, Director of Central Co-operative Bank in Amritsar had gone to visit relatives in a farm in Pilibhit in Uittar Pardesh. One morning a jeep drove up to the farm with a team of ‘doctors’ attired in white coats. They said that a V .LP was coming to the village to inaugurate a gov’t clinic and they wanted some respectable citizens. They requested Mr Piara Singh to accompany them. He ended up at the Durgiana mandir cremation ground on 16-12-92.

Mr Pargat Singh was under going treatment at the Guru Nanak Hospital, Amritsar. He was abducted by the Raja Sansi police and his unidentified body was brought to the Durgiana Mandir cremation grounds on 5-11-92.

The procedures followed by the Punjab police have been in abrogation of its own rules. The Punjab Police Rules No 3 Rule 25.38 in Chapter XXV, lays down the procedure as.;

If a body is unidentified the officer making the investigation shall record a ceareful description of it, giving all marks , peculiarities, deformities and distinctive features, shall .take finger impressions and in addition to taking all other reasonable steps to secure identification shall, if possible, have it photographed and in case where such action appears desirable a description published in the criminal intelligence Gazette.

Unidentified corpses should be handed over to any charitable society which is willing to accept them and ifno such society comes forward they should.then be buried or burned.
• These procedures were not followed by the police. And contradicting its own records, the police has given the identity of the body and even the village of the person but later disposed ofit as ‘unidentified’ or ‘unknown.’ The nature of deaths were not given and post mortems were avoided.

The human rights wing of the Shiromani Akali Dal is concerned at the large number of unidentified bodies cremated and feel that a national and an international enquiry needs to be started into this horrendous crime. The relatives of the people who have ‘disappeared’ need to be informed where possible so that they can perform last rites.

Thank You,

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PANJAB AND HARYANA

AT CHANDIGARH

Civil Writ Petition No.   _ of 1995

J.S.Dhillon son of S. Vijay Singh
Resident of 672, Phase vi, Mohali, Distt. Ropar.
…………..Petitioner

Versus

1, State of Panjab through Chief Secret.arY, Panjab•Govt. Chandigarh
2, Secretary, Department of Home Affairs, Panjab Govt.
Chandigarh.

Respondents.

+ Civil Writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India by way of Public Interest L.itighation for issuance of writ of Mandamus or any other appropriate writ order, or direction be issued deirecting the respondents to order an independent probe into the cremation of thousands unclaimed of unidentified bodies in the Distt Amritsar. It is further prayed that the report of the independent agency be made public and families whose children are missing from quite some time be informed about the whereabouts of thei children, so that their eternal wait may stop. 

Respectfully showeth,

1, That the petitioner is resident of MOhali and is citizen of India, hence competent to invoke extraordinary writ jurisdiction of this Hon’ble court.’

2, That the petitioner is a_human rights activist and is also a member of Akali Dal (J\lllritsar), Human Right1;1 _Wing. The Human Righta Wing of Akali Dal(A) conducted a suryey of cremation groilnds in Distt. Amritsar and found that thousands_ of bodies have been cremated in these cremation grounds at the behest of different police stations in the.area as being unclaimed or unidentified. During he survey_ o:t; the a_:i:.eas ,,. i_t was also found that about two thousand families, are,. iI\,.c,J/:l-e_ eternal wait for their children to return as._ they do n_ot; believe the police version as to whether their, chil_qren . are dead or alive. In number of cases where the police claimed that the man was dead was in fact found alive. In one Harjit I, Singh’s case belonging to Butter Kalan ,Teh. Baba Bakala, the police claimed that Harjit was killed_in an encounter on 12 th April,93. A hebeas Corpus petition was filed by’ his father Kashmir Singh in this Hon’ble court and a warrant Officer . .•,: . Mr. R.L.Bhatia was appointed to know the whereabouts of …., .: .. • ..-1t:–••!,. Harjit Singh. Mr. Bhatia visited Mall Mandi, Amritsar on 17th Oct.93 and found Harjit Singh standing in a celi..over there. Though Harjit Singh was whisked away from that plai:e,, qut ,t;h ­ fact is that Harjit was found alive even atte:r;_; h.f3 was daclared dead by the police five montns back. Such like incidents have totally shaken the faith of the people in the functioning of the police.

3, That as per the report submitted by the.Human Rights.wing Akali Dal (A), there are about two thousand families. in the border Distt of Amritsar who are waiting for their_ wards and kin to come back. Accordingto the report, several hundred bodiies have bewen cremated by the police in the. crematorium of the Municipal Corporation, Amritsar as being unclaimed. At the Municipal Crematorium, Patti, 400 bodiies as- being unclaimed or unidentified were cremated and at the crematorium at Tarn Taran, _the number is 700. A news .report to the said effect was published in different news papers. including The Tribune dated 2nd Jan.95. The said news item.is annexed along with as annexure Pl. The list of bodies cremated at Durgiana cremation grounds as bieng unidentified or unclaimed between Jan.92 to Dec.92. by Panjab police is annexed along with as annexure P2.

4, That the perusal of annexure P2 shocks the human conscience that so many persons were killed and disposed off in a clandestine manner, when thousand of families. are waiting for the return of their nearest ones that one day they will come back. The least that the govt. can do is to provide the correct indformation to these families about their kith and kin whose whereabouts are not known.

5, That now that the terrorism has been wiped out from the state of Panjab, the govt. should come out clean and provide the correct information and details of the. bodies cremated aS being unidentified or unclaimed. In the interest of justice, it is neccessary that an independent probe be ordered in to the whole matter to reach out the truth so that thousands of familis are given a sigh of relief.

6, That the law of the land provides that the life and liberty of an individual cannot be taken away except by due cause of law, but in the present case thousands of persons have been klled and disposed of in a most brutal manner.

7, That the respndents are liable to order an independent probe into the whole matter and also inform the parents of the deceased persons so that their eternal wait for their dear ones comes to an end.

8, That the main law point involved in the petition is:

i) Whether the respondents are bound to order an independent probe in to the cremation of thousands of unidentified and unclaimed bodies in the distt. of Amritsar from the last three years and also inform thousands of families about the whereabouts of their children who are missing from quite some time, in the interest of justice.

9, That the petitioner has no other such or equally efficacious remedy before him except by way of this writ_petition.

10, That the peitioner has not filed such or similar writ petition either in this Hon’ble court or Supreme Court of India.

IN the premises, it is respectfuly prayed that:
i, Need for certified copies of annexures may please be dispensed with.
ii, Need for advance notices may also be dispensed with.
iii, Petition be allowed with costs.

Issue writ of mandamus or any other appropriate writ ‘order or direction be issued directing the respondents to order an independent probe by C.B.I. or aome other independent agency in to the crematiorr of thousands of bodies in the cremation grounds of district Amritsar and also informed thousands of families about the whereabouts of their children so that their eternal wait comes to an end And for this the petitioner as duty bound shall ever pray.

Petitioner
Through COun!i.el

Verification:

Verified that the contents of paras l to are true and correct .to my knowledge. Paras and  are as per the legal advice which I believe to be true. No part of it ·is false and nothing material has been concealed therefrom.

Dated

Chandigarh.

Petitioner.

Recovery Dead bodies Date of Death Details No. of Bodies
4-1-92 Not known From P.S. Bias 01
16-1-92 13-1-92 Bhikhi V in Encounter one Dead Body 01
20-1-92 16-1-92 Male 20 year (No Details) 01
19-1-92   Male 23 year 02
    Gurprit P.S. Kathu Nangal, Village Chana  
    Gurdarshan @ Baghet Singh P.S. GaRrkhkuna 02
27-1-92 23-1-92 Unknown 01
30-1-92 28-1-92 Bullet Injuries Khalsa College, P.S. Sadar 01
  29-1-92 Bullet Injuries, Ranjit Avenue, P.S. Civil Line 01
1-2-92   Guru ki Vadali, Postmortem, Medical College. 02
3-2-92   Sukhdev Singh MW Jaduwa 01
6-2-92   Unclaimed Jandiala 01
15-2-92 14-2-92 Hussainova Bridge 01
22-2-92 19-2-92 40-Well, Krishna Nagar, Mafe-17, Male-35 yrs 02
18-2-92   Salman Bittu Vill. Liddah 01
21-2-92   Thana Kotwali-1 01
12-3-92   Unclaimed Encounter, Postmortem, Medical College. 01
21-3-92 17-3-92 Chamanwal Road 01
24-3-92 22-3-92 Chaman2 Road 01
29-3-92 26-3-92 Chaman2 Road 01
1-4-92 2-4-92 Sikh 26yrs. 01
1-4-92 1-4-92 No Entry – Dead Body-I 01
2-4-92 2-4-92 -Do- 01
2-4-92 2-4-92 -Do- 01
19-4-92 19-4-92 Partap NaZar 01
19-4-92 19-4-92 -Do- 01
26-4-92 27-4-92 Thana JanSaib Makbhoor 01
27-4-92 28-4-92 Thana Sadar 01
27-4-92 28-4-92 Thana Bias 01
1-5-92 1-5-92 Detail – 25yrs. Male Sikh, Postmortem Medical College 01
4-5-92 5-5-92 Jandiala 02
5-5-92 6-5-92 Thana de 01
16-5-92 12-5-92 Sukhwinder, Surjit and another one, P.S. Lonoke 03
14-5-92 Male-20, Male-23, Chamaru Road 02
16-5-92 16-5-92 Male-24, Details – Postmortem 01
20-5-92 Khublokie Drei 01
25-5-92 20-5-92 No Entry 01
19-5-92 Encounter – Sri Naaz 02
27-5-92 22-5-92 Ranjit Katha Nangal 01
22-5-92 Sucha Singh and two unknown, Meerankot 03
27-5-92 Male-28, Male-34, Female-31 03
27-5-92 Bullet Injuries, Male-23, Khalar 01
26-5-92 Bullet Injuries, Chamkur Sahib, Rousr 01
28-5-92 Male-25, Male-23, Sultan Vill – Encounter, Manawala 02
28-5-92 Davinder Singh, Partap Singh, Jandiala 02
31-5-92 Encounter, Dalbir Singh S/o Joginder Singh, Satnam Singh S/o Sher Singh 02
1-6-92 Near Verka-Male-28 – Postmortem 01
2-6-92 2-6-92 Male-27 01
01
3-6-92 Unknown 01
3-6-92 Ramuwal, Chohla i Sahib 01
  3-6-92 Jaswiot-jcx and Another one fab.ibgari Shukarchak 02
  5-6-92 Ranjit Singh, Chite k-ilna 01
  5-6-92 Nirru(il Singh S/o Bishan Sin!.,h , Padtri 01
    Sita S/o Annik Singh Padori 01
    Jagtiat S/o Daliip Singh kaito 01
    Sarwan S/o Mahinder Makhi 01
    Satnam S/o Jarnali Makhi 01
    Unknown, Saifong 03
  5-6-92 Unknown, Landala Naeta 01
  74-92 Baserke Gilau 01
  6-6-92 Bias 01
  12-6-92 Bias 01
13-6-92 18-6-92 Encounter-Postmox lam 02
  18-6-92 ChinaKhuud 01
  19-6-92 Fateboard Cheorian 02
13-6-92 20-6-92 Kalex-P. S. Anuila 01
13-6-92 20-6-92 Kulwani Singh and one merchanted P.S. Kakku Nangal 02
  24-6-92 Unknown 02
  24-6-92 Laskhavstudier, Jaswiotjc kaut Khalsa, Chohri Wala Bhalla-Sultanvind Gate, Miliant-Blutoinder Sin2h 1802. 02
  23-6-92 Unclaim ed….Vijil Bucci. 01
  24-6-92 Jaswiotjc, Encounter Madunder, Encounter Khatzwan 02
  24-6-92 Gurdajji Singh Bias 01
  26-6-92 Male-24 01
  24-6-92 Bhai Sukhdip Singh Vili Pal 01.
  26-6-92 Maia wala 01
26-6-92 28-6-92 Male-30, Female-22, Encounter-Postmortam, Medical imbille 02
  28-6-92 Encounter-Housing Board 02
  30-6-92 P.S. Mahita 01
  1-7-92 P.S. Ainoia 01
* 2-7-92 P.S. Bhaoa Khurd. 01
3-7-92 3-7-92 Suzjit Singh and Another one, Muchal- P.S. Jandiala 02
  5-7-92 P.S. Lo-ke 02
  6-7-92 Udham Siosh/Gaiso Singh, one Hoidentitch, Bridge-San,,-a Kin. 02
  7-7-92 Unknown-Thana Mehta 01
  10-7-92 Do-Daoa Jaddala 01
  11-7-92 soc:’thana Kathu Nana! 01
11-7-92 12-7-92 Manjit Singh/Dalip Singh, Baljinder Singh/Dalbit Singh, Ranjit Stoch Satibula 03
  14-7-92 Encounter-Male-25, Gaoda Nak’ Hbal Road 01
  13-7-92 Jaddala 01
  14-7-92 Subeg Singh Bastok, Bhaiyi 01
20-7-92 17-7-92 Badak Encounter 03
  16-7-92 Udeke Encounter-Paramit-Lrink Stoch 03
  17-7-92 Dhinka Encounter-Surindar Singh/ Dalip Stoch. 01
  18-7-92 Unclaimed 02
  18-7-92 Parlifilder/Satviod er, Dastmoriam, Medical Collaze. 02
24-7-92 22-7-92 Jabhowa Encounter-Jabbi Singh/Sajat Singh, Jerusalem, Singh/ Kishan Stoch 02
  22-7-92 Chouki Kamon. 01
  23-7-92 Paramiji/J as want, Ramdas 01
  24-7-92 Gurwinder, Singh, Sahisla UI
  25-7-92 Sukhdev, Sukha, Atari 01
  29-7-92 Kashmir And another one Thana Lonoke 02
  28-7-92 Postmortam MediCal Colic1c. 01
  28-7-92 Bulick Injuries-Hari Singh, Mangal Singh Manila 02
  31-7-92 Dilsher Singh, P.S. Ainsia 01
  1-8-92 Pzem, Singh, Viii. Khammu 01
  1-8-92 Bhiowal 01
  5-8-92 Male-19 + Male20, Encounter, Eatak Dhal Road, –Postmortam Medical College. * 02
  6-8-92 Achet Singh S/o Jal Singh, Encounter-P.S. Loooke 01
  6-8-92 Joginder Singh, Viii. Batur. 01
  6-8-72 Viii.Ludth-it 01
13-8-92 11-8-92 Encounter.Nawdi UI
  13-8-92 Viii. Plujuri 01
  16-8-92 Ranian 01
  15-8-92 Diluka 01
  19-8-92 Uncl3imcd, Burj Thana Malitha 01
  21-8-92 Postmartam Medical collc.c 01
  21-8-92 Thana Lodroke UI
       
  22.8.92 Majitha, Road By Pass 01
25.8.92 21.8.92 Do 01
  22.8.92 Do 01
25.8.92 23.8.92 Amrik, Singh aqd, anhar,Makherzincil 02.
28.8., 92 23.8.92 Saestar/Gurman Sin h___._ _
    H ar d i p Daega/Kuluvani Sin2b  
    Unknown Pul Nehar  
    Baway 03
26.8.92 26.8.92 M aloo k 03 Singh/Khajan Singh Mas, Singh/Chaoan Singh Uojdenliffegi Encounter JabinZir  
  30.8.92 27yrs Male 01 Makbuloura  
  1.9.92 Thana Ghariada-1- 01
7.9.92 2.9.92 Ville2e Rastiks 01
  5.9.92 Manzal Singh Malese Olokas 01
  7.9.92 Rabeci, Singh-Hera Kshmal, and Kalja-Bhanthal Bhomau 04
  3.9.92 Ville2e Jalal 01
  9.9.92 Sabbir, Singh Hohkun 01
5.9.92 13.9.92 Beldev, Singh Lakhyundar, Singh Jazdevais 02
5.9.92 13.9.92 Unknown Drain Malian 03
5.9.92 13.9.92 Dalbir Singh Balwinder Sahib Singh,Kuluvant Saiap P.S. Mehta 05
1.9.92 18.9.92 Encounter Parlap Nagar Postmortem MC. 02
1.9.92 16.9.92 -Centershiali 01
19.92 16.9.92 Sham Singh/Bhau Singh, Lakhumdet Singh/Harehand Singh Unknown Malax P.S. Kathu Naal 05
21.9.92 18.9.92 Unclaimed 01
21.9.92   Hengal Dolu Khera P.S.Bist 01
  17.9.92 Thana Matuba 01
  17.9.92 Unidentified 01
21.9.92 19.9.92 Thana Thasa 01
  20.9.92 Uacliamed, Ghatala 02
  20.9.92 Unclaimed Kathu NanRal 01
  20.9.92 Unclaimed Diluka Mehta 01
28.9.92 25.9.92 Swaran Siligh and another one Thana Loonka 02
  24.9.92 Gurji Singh/Mo hinder Singh, Ashok Kumar/Baldex Raj, Hermet and Ranjit Ibaian Lidhraj 04
  24.9.92 Sarbiset and Unclaimed Villegas Tsema 05
  25.9.92 Bajunder, P.S. Jandida 01
29.9.92 26.9.92 Jozsa Singh, Hardeen Hera, Gurman Juwal 04
  29.9.92 Kot-Khaba 01
3.10.92 30.9.92 Bullet Encounter 23yrs Male+26yrs Male Sakeed Lidham Singh Naar 02
  29.9.92 Ajatpour P.S. Mattha 03
  7.10.92 Bajwinder Singh Shabour 01
7.10.92 30.9.92 Adhut Kaur 02
  3.10.92 Chyinda 03
  2.10.92 Unclaimed Bogarsi 01
Recovery Dead Bodies Date of Death Details No. of Dead Bodies
27.10.92 23.10.92 Encounter 02
  23.10.92 P.S. Mehta 01
  26.10.92 Singla- 01
  26.10.92 Unknown Post-Max tom Xerks 01
  29.10.92 Villea-Padbari 01
  30.10.92 T e r s e m02 (Sema)AnoManP.S.Ramdas  
3.11.92 30.10.92 Mabatajan pura P.S. Jardala 03
  1.11.92 Maaili-Guratset-Kabali 02
9.11.92 3.11.92 “Randir Singh Chaos Singh Dalum” 01
9.11.92 3.11.92 Unclaimed-Faraz gazu 01
9.9.92 5.11.92 Paral Singh Bullen P.S. Kan Santi 01
5.11.92 Villea-Mallian 01
  6.11.92 Krishan-Anoop-Simo  
    Kuldesp-Uukoorra Neher Gate Barala 04
24.11.92 17.11.92 Sahib Singh, Jaayram Singh Urakizutikid Vilkes Kadian 04
24.11.92 19.11.92 Koril-Nasane Khan 05
  20.11.92 P.S. Ahula 01
  25.11.92 Gurdes Singh P.S Ol Dandier  
  24.11.92 P.S. Ratavani 01
  25.11.92 Encounter in Arjun Nagar 19yrs Malet-IcKrA Male 02
  30.11.92 Yarlam Singh +24Yrs Male Encounter P.S Chkrasar 02
5.12.12 2.12.92 0 a l w i n d e j o l Singh/Kartar Singh Village Ramdioli  
7.10.92 4.10.92 U n k a o w a 01
    Encounter
19.10.92 10.10.92 Unclaimed Kbase 02
  11.10.92 Blaiau Catan 01
  11.10.92 Behar 01
  11.10.92 Karin Narzel 01
  11.10.92 Bikramlii Kadhu Nana’al 01
  18.10.92 Unclaimed Thana Lopoka 01
  20.10.92 P.S. Main 01
  2.12.92 Unknown Dijasa Danddar. 02
  6.12.92 P.S. Lopoka 01
  6.12.92 Unknown Sabkod Uddan Singh Nager Zywinkle 01
  19.12.92 Unknown on 01 Sulapayaba 01
19.12.92 16.12.92 Subdako Singh 4tyu Male Razana Singh S/o Sangira Sing 24yrs Male Post Mortem Medical Collect 02
  2.12. 92 Sardar, Singh Khaledara 01
  25.12.92 PS. Jandida Guru 01
  25.12. 92 R S O Tanaka (Matsaya) 02
  25.12.92 Lakavander Singh Sakranat Singh Harpal Kaur Lakavander Singh Terisin Singh Guridul Singh Villo’a Dhulika 03
  27.12.92 Chatir, Singh Anna Oi Sinah MUSHabad – Udas own-Postmortem 01
  28.12.92 24yrs P.S, B-Ol Dirkion Botmanian 01
  30.12.92 D. alikas t-Kasan ir Shala P.S. Ainsha 01
    Jagir: Singh/Tiakur Ol Singh Ainsha 01
  30.12.92 Unknown Raeipur, 01 Ratantan 01
    Total Dead Bodies 300
    Name Recorded 11
    Unidentified 1-3
    Shal-Bocouoter 41
    Postmortem M.C. 24
    Females 5
Date Police Station No. of Bodies Remark.
23.7.92 Bhikhi Wind 3  
29-7-92 P.S. Valtoha 3  
26-7-92 P.S. Bhikhi Wind 3  
29-7-92 P.S. Valtoha 3  
1-8-92 P.S Valtoha 1  
2-8-92 Harike 1  
5-8-92 karon 1  
14-9-92 Harike 2  
16-9-92 Patti 1  
Ih-9-92 Harike 3  
16-9-92 Valtoha’ 1  
24-9-92 Harike 1  
25-9-92 Bhikhi Wind 2  
27-9-92 Patti 3  
6-10-92 Valtoha 2  
7-10-92 Valtoha 2  
10-10-92 Bhikhi Wind 2  
12-10-92 Khaita 1  
16-10-92 Valtoha 2  
18-10-92 Valtoha 1  
17-10-92 Patti 2  
17-10-92 Valtoha 2  
24-10-92 Khaitha 5  
29-10-92 Harike 3  
30-10-92 Patti 1  
7-11-92 Patti 4  
7-11-92 Bhikhi Wind 3  
15-11-92 BhikhiWind 3  
23-11-92 Valtoh4 1  
23-11-92 BhikhiWind 2